- Calder
- Caleboch
- Calhoun
- Caltrider
- Calvert
- Camerer
- Campbell
- Cardinal
- Carpenter
- Carroll
- Carter
- Case
- Catherine
- Chew
- Chronister
- Clarke
- Clemans
- Clemens
- Clements
- Elizabeth (abt 1704 - 21 Jun 1742)
- John (abt 1745 - Aug 1784)
- Mary (31 May 1739 - 1806)
- Clever
- Cline
- Coffman
- Cole
- Colegate
- Colerighter
- Collier
- Colon
- Coltrider
- Commeron
- Comp
- Conner
- Conrad
- Conway
- Cook
- Cooper
- Cope
- Copeland
- Copenhaver
- Coriell
- Corle
- Cornbower
- Corwin
- Couch
- Cox
- Crabtree
- Craft
- Craig
- Craigg
- Cramer
- Craumer
- Craven
- Cregger
- Creighton
- Crew
- Crist
- Cromer
- Crowl
- Croyle
- Cullum
- Cummings
- Cunningham
- Curry
- Curtis
- Dadd
- Dagen
- Leah (18 Sep 1837 - 7 Dec 1889)
- Dalein
- Daley
- Danner
- Davidson
- Davis
- Day
- Deagan
- Deagen
- Leah (18 Sep 1837 - 7 Dec 1889)
- Deardorff
- Deaver
- Decker
- Dehoff
- Delap
- Ann (abt 1687 - Dec 1741)
- Delisle
- Dell
- Demmy